Google’s flagship Gemini large language model has temporarily halted its image generation feature for human subjects following criticism over its representation of race. The latest controversy emerged when Gemini generated images of Vikings and German World War II soldiers—iconic groups historically associated with whiteness—depicting them instead as people of color.
In response to the backlash, Google announced via X (formerly Twitter) that they are actively addressing these concerns. The company stated, "We’re already working to address recent issues with Gemini's image generation feature. While we do this, we're pausing the image generation of people and will re-release an improved version soon."
Although no specific images were mentioned in Google’s announcement, various outputs from the model circulated widely on social media, prompting further discussions and critiques. Among the notable examples shared included images of a pope and medieval knights, showcasing the model's inconsistent outputs. Currently, Gemini's image generation capabilities are limited to the U.S. market, and any attempts this week to create an image of a person were blocked.
Experiments with Gemini Advanced, the paid version of the platform, demonstrated challenges in generating specific human images. For instance, when prompted to create an image of the pope, the output was an abstract representation filled with blue and white swirls. Similarly, requests for images of German soldiers from WWII were met with a refusal to generate. However, when asked for a simple bear image, Gemini produced a satisfactory result.
This situation has ignited discussions around the perceived "wokeness" of the Gemini model. Critics have pointed out that obtaining images representing white individuals was surprisingly difficult. Debarghya Das, a former Google software engineer, tweeted about the challenges, stating it was “embarrassingly hard to get Google Gemini to acknowledge that white people exist.”
Tesla CEO Elon Musk added fuel to the discussion by commenting that Gemini was “just the tip of the iceberg.” He responded to a post that claimed inherent wokeness and “anti-whiteness” were integrated into the model. Musk suggested that these trends might also influence other Google products, including Google Search, without providing further details.
Musk has been vocal about the pursuit of truth and has ventured into AI with his own startup, xAI, which aims to foster a genuine understanding of the universe. This initiative has led to the development of Grok, an AI chatbot designed to rival ChatGPT, characterized by its minimal filters and commitment to a broader definition of freedom of speech. Grok's responses often differ from those of other AI systems, reflecting Musk's distinctive approach to technology and discourse.
As discussions continue, the landscape of AI image generation remains a focal point for both innovation and debate, highlighting the complexities of representation and technological accuracy in an evolving digital world.
Ranking
