Claude developer Anthropic positions itself as a company committed to altruism and ethical advancements in artificial intelligence. However, the Amazon-backed startup is now facing a lawsuit from Universal Music Group and several other recording companies over allegations of copyright infringement. Universal, which represents high-profile artists such as Taylor Swift, Ariana Grande, and Drake, along with Concord Music Group and ABKCO, claims that Anthropic unlawfully scraped songs for training data without obtaining necessary permissions.
The lawsuit contends that Anthropic's AI chatbot is capable of generating "identical or nearly identical copies" of lyrics from the songs it allegedly scraped. In particular, Claude reportedly produces near-verbatim lyrics from songs like Gloria Gaynor's iconic "I Will Survive." A recent examination confirmed that the chatbot can indeed replicate the song's lyrics word-for-word. Furthermore, the complaint highlights that Anthropic's models can generate plaintiffs' lyrics even when users do not explicitly request them, as demonstrated when attempts were made to generate lyrics about specific topics using the chatbot.
As highlighted in the lawsuit, "Publishers embrace innovation and recognize the great promise of AI when used ethically and responsibly. But Anthropic violates these principles on a systematic and widespread basis." The recording companies are seeking statutory damages of up to $150,000 for each instance of infringement. They are also requesting a share of Anthropic's profits derived from the alleged infringement, along with coverage for their legal expenses.
### Copyright Concerns
The lawsuits assert that Anthropic has copied extensive amounts of song lyrics without authorization while training its Claude model. Universal contends that by allowing public access to Claude, Anthropic indirectly enables and encourages copyright infringement, as users can retrieve unauthorized copies of lyrics through the chatbot. Moreover, by charging a monthly fee for Claude Pro, which is set at $20, Anthropic potentially profits from these infringements.
The complaint points out that Anthropic has allegedly stripped copyright management information, such as songwriting credits, from the lyrics it reproduces in its AI-generated outputs. Universal and other plaintiffs argue that Anthropic is violating their exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute, display publicly, and create derivative works based on the lyrics.
Like many in the industry, Anthropic maintains closed AI models to protect its technologies. While the company endorses independent assessments of its models in alignment with governmental AI guidelines, it has not revealed details about the core structure of its systems.
### Universal's Partnerships and Copyright Protection Efforts
In an effort to safeguard its music rights against the challenges posed by AI, Universal has implemented a proactive strategy. Recently, the company reached an agreement with YouTube, the largest video-sharing platform, to ensure that music artists are not unlawfully replicated. Consequently, AI-generated content monitoring has become a crucial aspect of YouTube’s safety protocols.
Despite these protective measures, a surge of so-called AI covers—where artificial intelligence is used to impersonate a singer's voice—has proliferated on YouTube. While many of these instances have been removed following Universal's copyright claims, numerous AI-generated tracks continue to circulate.
Furthermore, Universal has threatened to take action against Spotify if the streaming service does not remove AI-generated tracks uploaded by Boomy. This move highlights the record label's commitment to policing unauthorized usage of its artists’ work.
In addition to pursuing legal recourse against Anthropic, Universal recently forged a partnership with BandLab, a cloud-based music creation platform, focused on promoting ethical usage of copyrights in the context of AI. Both organizations aim to devise strategies that uphold pro-creator standards, ensuring that emerging technologies benefit the creator community responsibly. Earlier, Universal also formed a licensing agreement with Google pertaining to its artists’ voices for incorporation into AI-generated music.
This intricate web of legal challenges, partnerships, and industry dynamics underscores the ongoing conversation surrounding AI technology and the critical importance of ethical practices in music creation and distribution.
Ranking
